God reproves samuel for mourning saul, but tells him to go to bethlehem to a man named jesse. Now the spirit of the lord had departed from saul, and an evil spirit from the lord tormented him. How long was the ark of the covenant at abinadabs house. Yet a little later, after davids fight with goliath, saul is made to enquire from his chief captain as to the identity of the giant slayer i samuel 17. This move was only accepted when the accurate genealogical status of an individual was clear from the bookscontext. The philistines gather together against israel at ephesdammim, and saul and his men pitch their camp near the valley of elah, 1 samuel 17. All israelite men were required to attend 3 annual feasts at the central sanctuary deut. Of the two traditions in the hebrew text about davids entry into sauls service, the greek translation retains only the one found in vv. So in 1 samuel 15 saul waged a major campaign against the amalekites, but in just that one city of the amalekites. Apr 10, 2017 the capitalistchristian contradiction exposes the political, economic, and spiritual contradictions in our society and the church.
He is pleased with the counsel, and desires them to find such a person, 1 samuel 16. Samuel is sent from ramah to bethlehem, to anoint david, 1 samuel 16. Apologetics press the genealogies of matthew and luke. A contradiction requires an affirmation and denial of the same.
One of the charges of contradiction brought by skeptics against the bible is the surface appearance of contradiction between matthew s genealogical list 1. The first book of samuel tells the story of israels transition from a theocracy, or state ruled by a religious leader, to a monarchy, or state ruled by a political leader. The story of samuel begins with, funnily enough, the birth of samuel. Thanks for the question, but i disagree with your conclusion. Now viewing scripture range from the book of 1 samuel chapter 17. David, the king proven 1 samuel 1631 as the third division of the book opens we see samuel mourning for saul. And it was not a rock that david slew him with, but with a stone he slew him. Although they are separate books in modern bibles, the books of 1 samuel and 2 samuel were originally one book. There are not contradictory accounts of sauls death in scripture. As a result, the king made david his armor bearer 1 samuel 16.
Also similar to the textual situation in jeremiah is the fact that in 1 2 samuel the hebrew text from the dead sea scrolls 4qsama generally aligns with the septuagint over against the mt. To be a christian is to be a follower of jesus christ. Obviously davids army was a much smaller one, and the number of amalekites killed were much fewer as well only 400 escaped 1 samuel 30. In those days if a prophet came to visit you, it was largely because there was a problem. But samuel said, this is not the one the lord has chosen. Alleged contradictions and inaccuracies 1 samuel 15. In 1 samuel chapter 16, the lord rejects saul as the king of the israelites, but samuel grieves anyway. Can we harmonize the two meetings of david and saul. This contradicts the scene preceding the battle, where saul and. The decay in the house of eli is so much graver as the priesthood is concerned also which ought to be the medium between god and the people. The third major division of samuel recounts the steady demise of saul and the selection and preparation of david for the kingship. In 1 samuel 1618the story of the encounter of david and goliath and.
A general reading through the text of 1 samuel 1617 has led some bible. After being raised by the priest eli in temple, samuel becomes gods number one prophet. David, the apple of gods eye, was one of the greatest characters of all times. Feb 02, 2008 as in the book of jeremiah, there is quite a difference between the septuagint text of 1 2 samuel and the masoretic text of 1 2 samuel. And the lord said, take an heifer with thee, and say, i am come to.
About the book of 1 samuel its author, date and purpose. How many generations were there from the babylonian exile until christ. Samuel chose his native place for his usual official residence, and made it a centre of religious worship by building an altar to jehovah. Enduring word bible commentary 1 samuel chapter 16. Sauls attendants said to him, see, an evil spirit from god is tormenting you. Up until this point in biblical history, the israelites have not had a king. Please explain the contradiction created in 2 samuel 24. Paul tobin, in an article titled internal contradictions in the bible, summed up the. David, the king proven 1 samuel 16 31 as the third division of the book opens we see samuel mourning for saul. In a book dealing for the most part with the reigns of israels first two kings, saul and david, it is significant that the author chose not to include a birth narrative of either of these men, but to describe the birth of their forerunner and anointer, the prophet samuel. The capitalistchristian contradiction exposes the political, economic, and spiritual contradictions in our society and the church.
Israel starts out as a nation of loosely affiliated tribes led by priests and religious heroes, but it becomes a nationstate led by a centralized king. In 1 samuel 16, saul hired david to play the harp for him, and yet, in chapter 17, after david killed goliath the giant, saul did not seem to recognize who he was. As is always the case, the charge of contradiction is premature and reflects an immature appraisal of the extant evidence. Critical scholars tend to believe it was the result of much more piecing together, and some of them date its final form as late as 500 b. But its really a story about how the enemy of the soul attacks the body of christ.
The lord has really been ministering to me about some things in 1 samuel 12, 16 and 17. If the bible is an inspired record from god, how are these two passages apparently contradictory to be explained. A second reason saul might have failed to recognize david is because he may have lapsed into another unreliable mental state. Posted on may 11, 2007 by john oakes wrote in general, supposed inconsistencies in the bible, theology and doctrinal questions. And the two sons of eli, hophni and phinehas, the priests of the lord, were there. Why samuel and chronicles sometimes contradict each other. Paul tobin, in an article titled internal contradictions in the bible, summed up the skeptics argument by stating that 1 samuel 16 clearly shows that davidwas known to saul.
Someone separated it into these two parts in order to make it more convenient to copy. Does the bible contradict itself in 1 samuel 15 and 27. Sauls erratic behavior is attributed to a change in the lords relationship with him. In one of the visions of the prophet ezekiel, a man with a writers inkhorn in his hand was commissioned to set a mark upon the foreheads of the men that sigh and cry for all the abominations that be done in the midst of jerusalem. Is this is a genuine contradiction, or is there a logical solution. Newest contradiction questions biblical hermeneutics. And when they had counted, behold, jonathan and his armorbearer were not there. Apologetics press did saul know david prior to goliaths. Here ends the first division of the book, which records samuels life and work as the last of the judges, in connexion with the old order of things. Apologetics press did saul know david prior to goliaths death.
Although he is first mentioned in the book of ruth as the son of jesse, we find. Chapter 16 begins with samuel mourning for saul as one would mourn for the dead. Also, note the size of davids army 600 men 1 samuel 27. Samuel had jesse present all of his sons so that the anointing from god could commence the next king over gods people. Sauls intermittent deviation from normalcy is seen throughout the book of 1 samuel cf. The books of samuel, 1 samuel and 2 samuel, form part of the narrative history of israel in the neviim or prophets section of the hebrew bibleold testament, called the deuteronomistic history, a series of books joshua, judges, samuel and kings that constitute a theological history of the israelites and aim to explain gods law for israel under. The whole section, therefore, has this construction. However, samuel told them his mission and they moved forward.
It points out how americas capitalist system creates and maintains economic inequality, political corruption, economic exploitation, racial oppression, and spiritual poverty to worship the almighty dollar bill. Let me point out one factor you may be overlooking, and then perhaps comment on a couple of your questions. The spirit of the lord departs from saul, and an evil spirit comes upon him, 1 samuel 16. The words of the lord are pure words and to rightly divide his word 2timothy 2. But this is the first mention of his name, which means beloved or loved one.
First, it would not be unusual that a busy preoccupied king had not taken. God rebukes him and tells him to arise and anoint the new king 1 samuel 16. Please explain the contradiction created in 2 samuel 24, where it says satan incited david and 1 chron 21 where it says god incited david. Sauls questions about the identity of david in 1 samuel 17 create a rather difficult problem in light of 1 samuel 16, especially 1 samuel. But his armor bearer would not, for he was greatly afraid. In 1 samuel 16, saul hired david to play the harp for him, and yet. However, it should be noted that davids earlier being described as a valiant, mighty man and a man of war could.
276 960 198 391 1272 958 279 1451 1548 395 1374 368 1040 690 830 326 295 1495 808 1485 293 178 989 1035 433 313 389 153 847 1368 360 421 1018 234 947 673 7 1338 1236 1419 536 1139 1291 90